Reviewboard Magazine
milk chocolate
73
Reviewboard Signal / Review

milk chocolate

Household › Food & Beverages
Hershey'ssnacks03424005Reviewboard opinion: good

milk chocolate from Hershey's in snacks gets a Reviewboard buying read based on product details, price context, and buyer feedback. Reviewboard has a current national single-unit average price reference. No member discount is attached right now.

Product recall history

Matching historical recall records were returned. Check package codes, dates, and lot details against the official record before deciding whether a recall applies to your item.

Source: FDA food enforcement reports. Recall databases provide historical context and may not reflect the current lifecycle status of every recall.

F-1768-2019 — Class II

Product: HERSHEY'S CHOCOLATE PUDDING - 4PK/3.875OZ CUPS UPC: 4300006730

Why it was recalled: Products were not held at an appropriate temperature due to a mechanical malfunction during transportation.

Recall action: Voluntary: Firm initiated

Date initiated: 20190617

F-0598-2023 — Class III

Product: Cafe' Intermezzo Light and Dark Torte 5 lbs Ingredients: Dark Chocolate Cake, Water, Vegetable Oil, Coffee, Cream Cheese Frosting (Cream Cheese, Sugar, Butter, Shortening, Vanilla Extract), Chocolate Pudding Mix, Chocolate Cake Crumbs, Hershey's Syrup, White Chocolate Flutes. Contains: Milk, eggs, wheat and soy. May contain tree nuts and peanuts.

Why it was recalled: Firm did not list sub-ingredients. Undeclared Red 40. Remaining major allergens were listed in contains statement and/or ingredient list.

Recall action: Voluntary: Firm initiated

Date initiated: 20230130

F-0594-2023 — Class III

Product: Cafe' Intermezzo Cookies and Cream Cheesecake 6 lbs Ingredients: Eggs, Cream Cheese, Sugar, Oreo Crust (Oreo Crust (Oreo Cookies, Butter), Oreo Cookies, Vanilla Extract, All-Purpose Flour, Hershey's Syrup, Corn Starch. Contains: Milk, eggs, wheat and soy. May contain tree nuts and peanuts.

Why it was recalled: Firm did not list sub-ingredients. All major allergens were listed in contains statement and/or ingredient list.

Recall action: Voluntary: Firm initiated

Date initiated: 20230130

F-0591-2023 — Class III

Product: Cafe' Intermezzo Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Cheesecake 6.5 lbs Ingredients: Cream Cheese, Eggs, Sugar, Chocolate Ganache (Chocolate Chips, Heavy Cream), Peanut Butter, Graham Cracker Crust (Graham Cracker Crumbs, Butter Sugar, Vanilla Extract, Cinnamon), Reese's Cups, Vanilla Extract, Peanut Butter Sauce (Peanut Butter, Brown Sugar, Butter, Corn Syrup, Confectioner's Sugar, Vanilla Extract), Hershey's Syrup. Contains: Milk, eggs, peanuts, wheat and soy. May contain tree nuts.

Why it was recalled: Firm did not list sub-ingredients. All major allergens were listed in contains statement and/or ingredient list.

Recall action: Voluntary: Firm initiated

Date initiated: 20230130

F-0359-2023 — Class I

Product: Pilgrim's Roasted Nut'Z Chocolate Toffee Almonds are packaged by hand into either the 8 oz Plastic Cone Bags or 8 Oz Pouch Bags. Label declares Almonds, Sugar, Hershey's Cocoa Powder, Ghirardelli Sweet Chocolate Powder, English Toffee Syrup.

Why it was recalled: Chocolate Toffee Almonds product is recalled due to undeclared milk and soy lecithin.

Recall action: Voluntary: Firm initiated

Date initiated: 20230202

73Reviewboard score
goodReviewboard opinion
$1.48National average single-unit price
August 14, 2026Signal updated
The full Reviewboard review

Our complete buying opinion

Written for the current Reviewboard score of 73.0/100 · good · 931 words

The Hershey's milk chocolate in the snacks category receives a Reviewboard buying recommendation of 73.0 out of 100, with an opinion of good. This rating and opinion are consistent with the editorial assessment that while public buyer feedback suggests some general dissatisfaction with the brand, the product itself scores well based on available data, factoring in the context of its market price and documented safety history.

Identity and Market Context

The product under review is milk chocolate from the Hershey's brand, categorized within the snacks segment. When considering this item, it is important to understand its place in the market. The current market average price for this single unit is $1.48 USD. This context helps shoppers evaluate the value proposition when making a purchase.

Performance and Usability

As a snack food, usability revolves around the expected quality of the chocolate experience. While specific performance measurements are not provided in this review, the overall assessment suggests that the product meets expectations based on the Reviewboard’s evaluation. The practical usability is centered on whether the taste and texture align with consumer desires for milk chocolate.

Safety and Quality History

When examining safety and quality, it is necessary to look at the documented history associated with the brand. There are several voluntary recall records associated with various Hershey's products, including issues related to temperature control during transportation and the declaration of sub-ingredients. These incidents highlight past concerns regarding ingredient listing and handling procedures that consumers should be aware of when purchasing.

Public Feedback

Public feedback gathered from customer reviews indicates a generally negative sentiment across the board. For instance, customer ratings for Hershey's Chocolate have been low, with some sources noting an average rating of 2.7 stars from numerous reviews. This suggests that while the product exists, there is significant dissatisfaction among some consumers regarding their purchases.

Who Should Consider This Product

This milk chocolate may suit shoppers who are primarily focused on the product itself and are willing to weigh the documented safety history alongside general consumer sentiment. Given the context of the Reviewboard’s assessment, it is suitable for those who prioritize a specific snack item within the market.

What a Buyer Should Verify

Before purchasing, buyers should verify current pricing and check for any available offers, as noted in the editorial guidance. Furthermore, consumers should be mindful of the broader context of product recalls mentioned in the safety records to ensure full awareness regarding ingredient declarations and handling standards.

Final Buying Recommendation

Based on the synthesis of product details, market context, and the Reviewboard’s evaluation, the buying recommendation is positive. The product is deemed acceptable, leading to a final score of 73.0 out of 100. Shoppers should proceed with caution, verifying current pricing and being aware of the documented history associated with the brand.

The final buying recommendation is consistent with the Reviewboard score of 73.0 and opinion of good. The product is rated as good because it balances acceptable quality assessment against noted public dissatisfaction and historical safety concerns.

When you are standing at the shelf, the Reviewboard’s assessment of 73.0 and the opinion of good serves as a balanced starting point for your decision. This score suggests that while there are known areas of concern reflected in past consumer reports and safety notices, the product still holds a place in the market as an acceptable choice for many shoppers. Understanding this means recognizing that 'good' does not equate to flawless; it reflects a middle ground where the product functions adequately despite documented historical issues.

Practical buying guidance requires you to look beyond the single score and consider the context provided by the safety records. The fact that several recalls have occurred, addressing issues like temperature control or ingredient listing for related items, signals that vigilance is necessary. For this specific milk chocolate, a buyer should treat the product as one item among many where historical scrutiny has been applied. Always verify current packaging against any recent updates or notices, even if they are not directly tied to this exact unit, as these incidents demonstrate a pattern of regulatory attention within the broader category.

Furthermore, the public feedback paints a picture that must be factored into your personal experience. The noted dissatisfaction among customers suggests that taste and overall satisfaction can vary widely from person to person, even with a widely recognized brand. If you are highly sensitive to ingredient transparency or past quality control issues, this context should weigh heavily on your decision. Conversely, if you prioritize accessibility and general snack enjoyment over absolute perfection, the product remains viable within the market context provided.

To make the most informed choice, focus your verification efforts on what is immediately accessible: the current price point relative to the market average, and any immediate availability or offers. Since specific performance measurements are absent, usability relies heavily on established consumer expectations for a mass-market chocolate item. Buyers should use the documented recall information not as an absolute barrier, but as an indicator that due diligence regarding product history is always recommended when selecting food items.

Ultimately, the decision rests on your personal risk tolerance. If you are comfortable accepting the known historical context while still seeking a widely available snack, this product aligns with the established rating. If meticulous scrutiny of every past safety notice is paramount, then further investigation into the specific details of those past campaigns would be necessary before purchase.

In conclusion, the Reviewboard has landed on a balanced perspective for this item. The final buying recommendation remains based on this assessment: 73.0 out of 100, with an opinion of good.

Public buyer feedback

Public buyer feedback skews negative. Checked 5 public results with 3 positive and 6 negative cues. One public result noted: Read 2 honest reviews and 18 complaints about Hershey's Chocolate , rated 1.0 out of 5 by chocolate enthusiasts and sweet treats. Share your experience on ComplaintsBoard.

Similar reviews you may find useful